This week didn’t seem like much. Trump didn’t win in Iowa. There was kerfuffle over Roosh, which, like most kerfuffles generates orders of magnitude more heat than light. Trump and Bernie “win” in New Hampshire. Yawn. But some of the best minds in the reactosphere were at work penning some real gems. Why watch the first draft of history, when you can turn in here to This Week in Reaction and read second and third drafts? If I had to characterize this week (other than several genuinely standout articles which I’ll get to in a minute), I would point to the collective awakening of the Wider Reactosphere to the strategic wisdom of the passivist approach.
Reactionary Future has some imprecations Against consensus. Also a lesson from the General Piquemal arrest on how not to become worthy. Spandrell has his own take on the situation in Europe, bedecked with lessons from (relatively recent) Chinese history. “Situation”, that is, for insufficiently welcoming Europeans, I mean.
Over at The Future Primaeval, Harold Lee has another gem: An analysis of The Obedient Rebels. He contrasts the quite radical schemes of 60s-era student radicals with the purely verbal shenanigans of the current crop. It seems like we can’t even get Quality Campus Radicals™ these days.
Bradley Campbell and Jason Manning wrote an insightful paper contrasting three different moral regimes. In an honor culture, you’re supposed to defend your honor through your own personal efforts. In a dignity culture, insults have less impact, and you’re supposed to delegate enforcement to agreed-upon civic institutions. In a victim culture, insults matter a great deal once again, but the correct response is to assume a powerless victim role and basically passively request that powerful other people, usually institutions, step in and do something about it.
speaks to a student culture that has internalized powerlessness, cowardice, and lack of agency. The world is way bigger than you, and your only hope to get things done is to passively broadcast your grievances and hope that some other institution takes up your fight.
Neoreaction, as I understand it, predicted the emergence of the Alt-Right as an inevitable outcome of Cathedral over-reach, and didn’t remotely like what it saw. Kick a dog enough and you end up with a bad-tempered dog. Acknowledging the fact doesn’t mean you support kicking dogs — or bad-tempered dogs. Maybe you’d be happy to see the dog-kicker get bitten (me too). That, however, is as far as it goes.
Ryan Landry, who pays attention to these things (and may someday be paid good money for it), tells us what actually happened…
Mr. Rick Wilson lost his head on national television and talked about the altright as if it were a bunch of Nazis that “masturbate to anime”. First, Rick, I think the kids masturbate to hentai, but let us not split hairs since you lost your cool on national television and signal boosted a bunch of “nazis” in your words. Second, you idiot, you made people google “altright”, and what they found was most likely not a bunch of nazis who masturbate to anime. It was guys like Richard Spencer, who keeps it classy and respectable.
Plus a lot more.
Mark Citadel (with whom Anthony and Antony and I spoke last Friday for an up-coming AtT episode–great guy!) touches on the alt-right/NRx cleavage Have You Failed the Entry Exam? He skewers some particularly egregious NatSoc Buffoonery™ that stained the carpet of a Millennial Woes hangout. Some of my best friends might be fashists, but only ironically. Mark Citadel wins an ☀“Official” #NRx Best of the Week Honorable Mention☀ on magisterial tone alone.
I haven’t given much attention to the passing of David Bowie, mostly because I didn’t think it was that important. To the extent that it is, and what we may learn from his history on earth, Joseph Pearce has a nice requiem: Fame, Fashion & Fascism: The Many Masks of David Bowie.
“NGO” stands for “non government organization”, but if an organization is actually non governmental, for example McDonalds, no one calls it an NGO. In practice, “NGO” means “US State Department Front Organization”. This is an open secret, as for example when they advertise for employees, they are apt to describe the openings as government employment.
The reason that they call themselves non governmental is that they actively campaign in US politics and foreign politics, which is illegal or embarrassing for the US government to openly do.
The religion of Massachusetts wound up conquering the US, and eventually the world, in large part because Virginia took religious freedom seriously, while Harvard and Massachusetts was unyieldingly and fanatically determined to extirpate it with fire and steel and still are unyieldingly and fanatically determined to extirpate it with fire and steel. When crazies and fanatics go up against moderate, compromising, and cynical cosmopolitans, the moderate and cynical cosmopolitans tend to get trampled.
Arthur, the Esoteric Trad, wonders Are Cities Culture Killers?—an ☀“Official” #NRx Best of the Week Honorable Mention☀ in its own right. Cities certainly seem to be that way today. Why? I doubt that this rôle stems from anything in the inherent nature of cities. In fact, cities should, in principle, be more orderly than their hinterlands. But good principles have a taken a back seat these last couple centuries. Continue reading This Week in Reaction (2015/12/27)